Permitting delays keep the Golden State behind in renewable generation

Ask most people which U.S. state generates the most renewable energy, and California likely comes to mind. It has one of the world’s largest economies, an international reputation as a clean-energy leader, and is committed to reaching a 100% clean electric grid by 2045. However, they would be wrong.

So why does America’s hub for oil and gas lead the nation in renewable energy by such a wide margin? Texas has created an environment that makes it easier to build, with far less red tape, while giving developers a reliable path to market. The clearest evidence of this success is transmission build-out.

Texas took a different approach, creating “competitive renewable energy zones” (CREZ). In 2008, the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) established five CREZ in West Texas and the Texas Panhandle in response to a directive from the state legislature. By 2013, the program had produced more than 3,500 miles of transmission lines capable of carrying 18,500 MW of electricity. Overall, it took roughly six years from approval to completion—or about eight and a half years from the original legislative directive—for a network that now serves the entire state.

This is also a story of how government bureaucracy ultimately stands in the way of progress. In Texas, a single regulating entity, PUCT, established transmission scenarios, selected companies to build the lines, determined routes, allocated costs across ratepayers, and oversaw construction. Renewable developers could follow the process transparently and reliably plan their own projects. In California, separate bodies handle planning, permitting, and construction, each with its own timeline, and a delay at one stage pushes back everything after it.

California’s politicians will say this isn’t a direct comparison, and they’re right. California’s figures represent individual transmission projects, while CREZ was one program creating many lines and establishing zones where future development was expected and planned. But that is the point: CREZ was a holistic development plan that created regulatory certainty enabling growth.